Thursday, February 11, 2010

Judge sends LCRP chairmanship issue to the ORP

Judge Charles Doneghy issued the following ruling today in the case filed by Jon Stainbrook and/or Megan Gallagher against Jeff Simpson over who is the chairman of the Lucas County Republican Party:

2/11/2010 1 Title : ORD:FIND FACT & CONCLUSION LAW
IN CONFORMITY WITH THE FORGOING CONCLUSIONS OF LAW,
THE COURT HEREBY ORDERS THAT THE MOTION TO INTERVENE FILED
BY JEFFREY SIMPSON AND PAUL HOAG IS SUSTAINED. THE COURT
FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE INTERVENING DEFENDANTS' ANSWER
BE FILED. THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT THE MOTION FOR
PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION FILED BY THE PLAINTIFF IS
OVERRULED. THE COURT FURTHER ORDERS THAT THIS MATTER IS
HEREBY STAYED PENDING ACTION ON THE SUBJECT MATTER HEREIN
BY DEFENDANT OHIO REPUBLICAN PARTY STATE CENTRAL COMMITTEE.

SEE FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW.

By denying the injunction requested by Stainbrook and Gallagher, the issue will go to the Ohio Republican Party's state central committee to decide which group of Republicans to recognize as the official party.

This is in accordance with state law and the judge really didn't have much leeway in the matter.

The judge also denied a request for class-action status on behalf of the Stainbrook/Gallagher faction:

2/11/2010 2 Title : ORD:OPINION ISSUED SEE JE
THE COURT HEREBY ORDERS THAT THE MOTION TO CERTIFY A
CLASS ACTION FILED BY THE PLAINTIFF IS OVERRULED.

SEE OPINION AND JE.
PARTY : -


In an interesting twist, the Toledo Free Press is reporting that Judge Doneghy also determined that neither the Simpson NOR Stainbrook group met and elected a chairman as required by law.

So now the state central committee will make their decision and, hopefully, the LCRP can get on with the business of fielding and supporting Republican (that is, conservative) candidates.

But don't expect Stainbrook to go quietly if things go against him in Columbus. He's vowed to do everything to maintain control, even if doing so is detrimental to the party he wants to lead.

Background posts in chronological order:

LCRP has a new chairman

The ruckus in the LCRP continues

Adding perspective to the LCRP power struggle

Surprise (not!) Stainbrook nominated for BOE

Stainbrook 'deems' Kriner and Olman resigned from BOE

LCRP Simpson group files complaints against Stainbrook

Another lawsuit and request for TRO in the quest for power in the LCRP

Republican clubs endorse Simpson

LCRP update

1 comment:

Brian Maxson said...

In all seriousness, Maggie, it doesn't seem as if much of Mr Stainbrook has "attempted" has been successful other than for making it to the Blade's pages.

Whether it be for candidates, party values, or even lawsuits, nothing he's done has been advantageous to the LCRP's reputation.

Because of the common-knowledge of the "intimate" relationship Mr Stainbrook has had with the publisher of the Blade in the past, John Block, I am convinced that this was a scheme by both to not only afford control of the political climate (combined with the various Democrat politicos that have been afforded audiences with Mr Block) to John Block, but imagine the sales of the papers as the political system is manipulated like a marionette.

And I truly believe that John Block, in his infinite wisdom, never imagined in a million years how big of a blunderer Jon Stainbrook turned out to be. John couldn't have imagined how big an ego Jon had.

Then again I could be wrong...

Google Analytics Alternative